Showing posts with label Mukherjee. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Mukherjee. Show all posts

A night full of Lokpal bill related drama

The government on Wednesday night took a tough stand and finance minister Pranab Mukherjee, said a source, made it clear to Anna Hazare’s associates that if anything happened to the fasting Gandhian, they would be held responsible. Also, the source said, the government was thinking of an evacuation operation late at night at the Ramlila Maidan.

At 11pm, Team Anna members Prashant Bhushan, Arvind Kejriwal and Kiran Bedi took to the stage at the maidan. While Kejriwal accused the government of reneging on its promise, Bedi said Mukherjee scolded them at the meeting. Hazare appealed to the crowd to remain non-violent if the police took him away forcibly.

Earlier in the day, the first meeting between the government and Team Anna made little progress. While everyone hoped that the all-party meeting in the evening would bring forth a solution, that did not happen. And the last meeting of the day, between Team Anna and Mukherjee, drew a blank.

In the evening, major political parties failed to reach a consensus after spending four hours at PM Manmohan Singh’s official residence discussing the situation, accusing Hazare and his aides of using pressure tactics and finally blaming the Congress for the mess. Once the government had realised that even the opposition parties were not in favour of the Jan Lokpal Bill, said the source, it decided to harden its stand.

Now, if anything goes wrong, the Congress can share the blame with all parties, the source said. This may explain why the last talks of the day failed and Team Anna complained that the “government’s attitude had changed from being conciliatory to combative”.

Bhushan told that the talks had failed and “we have to start from scratch”. Another meeting is scheduled between the government and Team Anna on Today. In effect, this means Hazare’s fast will move on to the 10th day, unless his health deteriorates and Team Anna members move him to hospital in the light of Mukherjee’s warning.

Kejriwal said he had asked Mukherjee if the government planned to send the police to Ramlila Maidan and the finance minister had told them that was not his call.

Though all the representatives told after the all-party meeting that they wanted a “strong Lokpal Bill”, the fact remains that they were unhappy with Team Anna's agitation and that they were making demands to suit their own political considerations.

After Singh started the discussions, his cabinet colleagues Mukherjee and home minister P Chidambaram took over and conducted the meeting. But it soon became evident that the parties were in no mood to reach a consensus. Sushma Swaraj of the BJP was instrumental in changing the statement that was issued after the meeting. While most parties were keen to bring in the bill prepared by UPA National Advisory Council member Aruna Roy, Swaraj put her foot down and, instead, forced everyone to accept the inclusion of only the Jan Lokpal Bill prepared by Team Anna, albeit with changes.

She insisted that the actions of MPs in Parliament be kept out of the Lokpal’s ambit. As for removing the Lokpal, she suggested that the power be vested in Parliament where members could impeach the Lokpal in a manner similar to the impeachment of the higher judiciary. The BJP was, however, keen that the lower bureaucracy be included in the ambit of the Lokpal.

The Samajwadi Party submitted a written representation asking for the judiciary to be kept out of the Lokpal's ambit while bringing NGOs and corporate houses in.

The Left also criticised the agitation. Gurudas Dasgupta of the CPI expressed his displeasure at “people [Team Anna] trying to run down Parliament”.

Towards the end of the meeting, all the parties, however, united to launch a scathing attack on the Congress party’s “inept handling” of the crisis and termed the discussion “a meeting that did not even have a prepared agenda”.

Three sticking points with government : Team Anna

There were three sticking points with the government including inclusion of lower bureaucracy in ambit of Lokpal, Team Hazare said Tuesday as they insisted on passage of anti-corruption legislation in the ongoing monsoon session of parliament.

Addressing the gathering at the Ramlila grounds after a meeting with Finance Minister Pranab Mukherjee and other ministers, Arvind Kejriwal, an associate of Anna Hazare, said that the government will convey its viewpoint on three of their demands including an institution of Lokayukta in every state and a citizens' charter for every government department.

Hazare is on a fast at Ramlila grounds which entered its eighth day Tuesday.

Kejriwal said that the citizens' charter should specify responsibility of government officials along with period of delivery of service and penalise them with deduction of salary in case the work is not done in the stipulated period.

He also said the government had agreed to show to the civil society members the bill aimed at checking corruption in judiciary.

"There is no major objection on other issues. It is a major achievement," Kejriwal said.

Prashant Bhushan, another associate of Hazare, said the government will tell Wednesday morning if the Lokpal bill can be passed in this session. Team Hazare members said that the session should be extended, if needed, to pass the bill.

He said the government did not show any objection to inclusion of prime minister in Lokpal's ambit. The demand has been a major bone of contention between the two sides in the past.

He said anti-corruption investigations will be conducted by the Lokpal and not Central Bureau of Investigation.

Bhushan said Article 105 of Constitution says that MPs were free in the way they speak and vote in Parliament and added that if complaints of corruption against MPs were investigated, subject to the relevant constitutional provisions, they had no ojections.

"Even if it is subject to (Article) 105, the Lokpal will be able to investigate," he said.

Bhushan said that government is likely to discuss demand for withdrawal of its Lokpal bill at a meeting of Cabinet Committee on Political Affairs (CCPA).

He said if the CCPA decides to withdraw the official bill and instead, introduces the Jan Lokpal bill in parliament, then they willl urge Hazare to end his fast.

"The whole country needs Anna. The country needs a moral leadership which only Anna can provide," he said.

"If doctors now say that at least drip is necessary even if you (Hazare) do not want to end fast, we will appeal (to Hazare) to agree to what doctors say," he said.

Kran Bedi, who was also a member of Team Hazare which took part in the talks, said that government had agreeed to conditions of civil society as only due to "meditation of Hazare".

She said the government was also worried about Hazare's health.

The first fromal talks of civil society members with the government since Hazare began his fast Aug 16 for a stong Lokpal bill lasted almost three hours.

Apart from Mukherjee, Law Minister Salman Khurshid represented the government at the talks. Congress MP Sandeep Dikshit was also present.